LK Advani: From BJP Marginalisation to Modi’s ‘Epoch-Maker’ – The Political Reinvention of a Hindutva Icon

Amalendu Upadhyaya
Posted By -
0

Why Has Narendra Modi Suddenly Rediscovered LK Advani? The Politics Behind the Praise

  • LK Advani’s Political Legacy: From Marginalisation by Modi to Celebration as an Epoch-Maker
  • Narendra Modi’s Tribute to LK Advani: Political Amnesia, Hindutva and the Battle for Legacy
Why has Narendra Modi suddenly begun celebrating LK Advani, the BJP veteran he once pushed to the political margins? From the Jain Hawala scandal and the 1990 Rath Yatra to the Babri Masjid demolition, caste discrimination allegations and the BJP's changing political leadership, Shamsul Islam examines Advani's controversial legacy and the political calculations behind Modi's renewed praise.
Narendra Modi with LK Advani – BJP veteran's political legacy, marginalisation and renewed recognition by Prime Minister Modi
Narendra Modi with LK Advani – BJP veteran's political legacy, marginalisation and renewed recognition by Prime Minister Modi


LK ADVANI FORCED INTO OBLIVION IS NOW EPOCH-MAKER FOR PM MODI

When Narendra Modi decided to extend his political role beyond his safe and secured borough, Gujarat to the national arena in 2013, BJP leaders like LK Advani and Murli Manohar Joshi not only constituted the top rung of the party leadership but also were the most popular leaders with the Hindu voters. Out of these two Advani had been the architect of making Ayodhya an emotional issue for Hindus, was present when the Babri mosque was demolished on December 6, 1992, functioned as deputy PM and Home Minister under Atal Bihari Vajpayee (2002-4). When BJP was out of power at the Centre, he was leader of the opposition (2004-9) and was invited to contest Lok Sabha elections from Gujarat by Modi. However, when PM Modi constituted his first ministry in 2014, Advani was not included. He was forced into oblivion.

The Advani’s descend had started in 2013 itself when Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi was chosen to head BJP’s election campaign committee for the 2014 general elections signalling Modi was BJP’s PM candidate. In protest Advani stepped down from key party posts in June 2013. According to a press report: “Mr Advani said most of the party's current leaders were ‘now concerned with their personal agendas’. He was upset over the appointment of controversial party colleague Narendra Modi as head of the BJP's election committee.”

[‘LK Advani: India BJP leader quits all party posts’, BBC, 10 June 2013. Link: LK Advani: India BJP leader quits all party posts - BBC News ]

But it made no dent. Modi and his coterie, led by Amit Shah, had captured BJP with the backing of RSS. That was the end of ‘Hindu hirday samrat’ Advani.

However, there seems to have been enormous change of heart on the part of PM who on Advani’s 100th birthday anniversary [November 8, 2026] visited his residence to greet him and in a widely circulated laudatory statement underlined the auspicious nature of his birthday by stating that “his birthday fittingly coincides with Diwali, a festival associated with Prabhu Shri Ram and the Diya, at a time when we are marking 75 years since the inception of the Jana Sangh, 125th Jayanti of Dr Syama Prasad Mookerjee and recently celebrated a hundred years of the RSS”.

According to Modi, “There are very few people whose lives have touched so many different chapters of modern India…As a youngster in 1947, he experienced the pain of leaving behind his familiar world in Sindh… Of course, an iconic moment in Advani Ji’s life was the Somnath to Ayodhya Rath Yatra. It changed the course of Indian society for the better... Advani Ji nurtured generations of karyakartas (members) and gave the party a clear foundation rooted in the principle of Nation First. Two qualities always set Advani Ji apart as a leader. First, his ideological clarity and intellectual sharpness…Second, the manner in which he exposed the pseudo-secularism propounded by a large section of the Indian polity for many years.”

PM also recalled Advani’s role during 1975-77 Emergency.  “The Emergency was a watershed moment in Advani Ji’s life. He was at the forefront of saving democracy and protecting the Constitution”.

[‘His life touched so many chapters of India’, The Indian Express, Delhi, November 8,2026. ]

This rebirth of Advani’s greatness courtesy PM Modi has brought once again under scrutiny the political career of this great Hindutva stalwart. This epoch maker was involved in many infamous activities when in command of politics as we will see in the following.

INVOLVEMENT IN HAWALA SCANDAL

On 25 March 1991, as per the court proceedings published by the Supreme court of India, Ashfak Hussain Lone, a person alleged to be an official of the terrorist organisation Hizbul Mujahideen, was arrested in Delhi. During his interrogation, the police learnt that his organisation was funded through hawala, using Surendra Kumar Jain and his family as a conduit. Based on this and further information received during Lone's interrogation, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) conducted raids on the premises of Surendra Kumar Jain, his brothers, relatives and businesses. During the raids, the CBI seized two diaries and two note books [known as Jain Diaries] at the premises which mentioned payments between Rs. 50,000 to Rs. 7.5 crore to Indian leaders namely L. K. Advani, V. C. Shukla, Devi Lal, Sharad Yadav, Balram Jakhar, and Madan Lal Khurana and an entrepreneur from Hyderabad Anwar Alvi.

Incidentally, Advani resigned as MP in 1996 because of the scandal.

It became a national issue when a renowned journalist and activist Vineet Narain filed a PIL in Supreme Court of India and two well-known Delhi based journalists Ram Bahadur Rai and Rajesh Joshi through their in-depth investigation made it a national issue. However, all please to convict the recipients of illegal foreign funds collapsed without convictions in 1997 and 1998 because the hawala records (including diaries) were decreed in court to be inadequate as the main evidence. It was facilitated by the April 1997 Judgment of Justice M. Shamim of the Delhi High Court which held that the Jain Diaries were not admissible as evidence under Sections 10, 21, and 34 of the Indian Evidence Act. The court held that the diaries did not qualify as books of account kept in the regular course of business and that the entries alone did not provide prima facie proof of payoffs or unlawful motives.

[‘Hc Quashes Hawala Charges Against Advani, Shukla’ April 9, 1997,]

BJP and Advani were immensely grateful to Justice Shamim for the favour became clear in 2000 when Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Advani were PM and home minister respectively. Shamim appointed as chairman of National Minority Commission of India shortly after retiring from the Delhi High Court on December 30, 1999.

PRACTITIONER OF UNTOUCHABILITY

The following report from correspondent Sanjay K Singh in The Statesman, Delhi exposed how deeply Advani was involved in practicing Untouchability:

“The worst of Indian caste prejudices was demonstrated in the heart of Delhi, in a function attended by among others, Mr. LK Advani. Organizers of a function in Vasant Kunj Institutional Area forced 10 families to leave their homes at 5 a.m. on February 1 [2002], because the latter’s presence would have ‘polluted’ the atmosphere at a havan. Mr. Advani attended the havan, which was followed by his laying the foundation stone for the Vedic Studies and social services. The organizers, the Sri Rama Vitthal Shikshana Sewa Samiti and the Sudesh Foundation, who had taken out newspaper advertisement announcing the function on February 1, could not be contacted despite repeated efforts by the correspondent.

The 10 families who were unceremoniously dragged out of their homes and asked to shift to a forest area 300 meters away, at 5 a.m. on February 1, belong to the Jusadh caste (originally from Mahoba area in Uttar Pradesh). They were told by the organizers that their presence at the venue of havan will be inauspicious. ‘Meri taang tooti hui hai aur mujhe phir bhi jane ko kaha kyonki hum jusadh hain. Bade log to dus baje aaye lekin hamen subah paanch baje hi thhannd mein bhaga diya (I have a broken leg but they told me to leave because I belong to a lower caste. Though the VIPs came at 10 a.m., we were forced to shift at 5 a.m. when it was freezing cold)’ said 55-year-old Jamuni Devi.” [The Statesman, Delhi, February 5, 2002.]

CHIEF DEMOLISHER OF SECULAR INDIA

PM eulogized Advani for Rath Yatra 1990 which paved the way for demolition of Babri mosque in 1992. In fact, it was bleeding of secular India on flimsy grounds.  It is true that traditionally, Hindus believe that Ram was born in the city of Ayodhya, but the issue is whether he was born exactly under the central dome (approximately measuring 150 cm x 150 cm) of the Babri Mosque as is claimed now by Hindutva’s flag-bearers. 

Even Indian Supreme Court which gave a partisan judgement on the Ayodhya title case in 2019, made two observations which made Hindutva claims unsustainable and rationale behind the Rath Yatra. 

Firstly, it stated: “The exclusion of the Muslims from worship and possession took place on the intervening night between 22/23 December 1949 when the mosque was desecrated by the installation of Hindu idols. The ouster of the Muslims on that occasion was not through any lawful authority but through an act which was calculated to deprive them of their place of worship.” [Supreme Court Judgment dated November 9, 2019, pp. 921-22] 

Secondly, on pages 913-14, it states that “On 6 December 1992, the structure of the mosque was brought down and the mosque was destroyed. The destruction of the mosque took place in breach of the order of status quo and an assurance given to this Court. The destruction of the mosque and the obliteration of the Islamic structure was an egregious violation of the rule of law.”

How sure Advani was of the historicity of the Hindu claim over Babri mosque was made clear when talking to Veer Sanghvi (July 20, 2003) he stated:

“It did not matter whether the historical Rama was actually born at the spot in Ayodhya. What mattered was that Hindus believed that he was born there. Faith took precedence over history.”

[Veer Sanghvi, ‘Let’s ignore the fanatics’, The Hindustan Times, July 20, 2003.]

HOBNOBBING WITH CIA

Advani as a senior ideologue and functionary of RSS like his alma mater was in constant touch with CIA is not a hidden fact. In post-independence India CIA had a big set-up in the US embassy, Delhi. In fact, Jean A. Curran, Jr. head of the CIA in Asia and Africa was stationed here. Another senior CIA official, Craig Baxter worked as a Political Attaché in the US embassy. While stationed at Delhi he authored a primer on Jan Sangh, a precursor of BJP titled, The Jan Sangh: A Biography of an Indian Political Party in 1969 in association with top RSS. Preface of the book is a clear confession how RSS and CIA were hobnobbing with each other. It reads:

“In writing this autobiography of the Jan Sangh I have been aided by many in India and in the United States…It is impossible to mention everyone, but three of the Jan Sangh have spent much time to aid me. Lalchand K. Advani, now the chairman of the Delhi Metropolitan Council, arranged for the use of back files of Organiser at my home, a necessity when my duties at the Embassy [US] permitted me only weekends and occasional evenings for research. Balraj Madhok, one of the principal members of the party and now a Member of Parliament, gave many hours, loaned books and related some of the lore of the party. Jagdish Mathur, office secretary, made available documents and files of the central office and tirelessly answered questions. After the dissertation version was completed, Messeres Advani, and Mathur and Dindayal Upadhyaya [sic], then general secretary and president until his death on February 11, 1968, looked over the text and made several valuable suggestions. Keval R. Malkani, editor of Organiser, allowed the use of files for some updating.

[Craig Baxter, The Jan Sangh: A Biography of an Indian Political Party, Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1969, p. viii.]

RSS, Advani or any other RSS leader mentioned in this Preface have never countered this claim.

SPINELESS ADVANI

It would be interesting to know what Balraj Madhok who died as RSS whole-timer in 2016 wrote about LK Advani with whom he had long association in his autobiography:

“The position of Lal Krishan Advani was like a puppet. He was not qualified for the post [presidentship of BJS] which was given to him after discarding many senior workers. I knew through my personal experience that he is a boneless wonder. He has neither personal integrity nor opinion. But he is lucky. The office which he had got due to the offerings (prasad) of Vajpayee and officials of Sangh, keeping aside its honour, he acted as a bonded labourer, for any work assigned to him.”

(Zindagi Ka Safar –3: Deendayal Upadhyay Ki Hatya Se Indira Gandhi Ki Hatya Tak, 2003. p. 146)

 

ADVANI’S VIP MIGRATION

Millions of Hindus and Sikhs bore the brunt of unspeakable Partition violence but Advanis migration was quite different. L.K. Advani left Karachi (in Sindh, present-day Pakistan) and travelled by a propeller aircraft to Delhi on September 12, 1947. He flew to India as a 19-year-old RSS worker to seek guidance and advice regarding the arrest of RSS members following a bomb explosion. His family migrated to India a month later. His rise in India was spectacular; within 20 years he was running metropolitan city of Delhi. There is not a similar example.

WHY MODI’S NEWFOUND LOVE FOR ADVANI

It may be a million-dollar question but answer is quite simple. Modi replaced Advani as ‘Emperor of Hindu Hearts’. He did not want Muslims to come to his meetings, ‘managed’ Supreme Court to deliver favourable decisions on all Hindutva projects like Ayodhya+Kashi+Mathura mosques, disenfranchisement of Muslims via SIR, cleansing of Indian Christians, uniform civil code, Waqf, demolition of madarsaa system, curtailing reservation etc. However, this Hindutva sheen was a camouflage to serve High Caste oligarchy, Hindu Corporates, International capital including the Chinese one.

The World Inequality Database confirmed that rise of top-end inequality between 2014 and 2023 has been particularly sharp, with a small percentage of top earners and billionaires capturing a massive share of national wealth and income. It was at the cost of Indian peasants, workers, small businesses, and middle classes. In last few years of Modi rule India witnessed massive protests by farmers, working class and latest rise-up by the youth of India, 80% of whom happen to be Hindus. PM Modi appeared to be a ruthless Emperor in clothes of a Hindu saint out to destroy livelihood of common Hindus. Modi wants the tag of ‘Hindu Hirday Samrat’ back and Advani can help him in this venture.

Shamsul Islam

November 16, 2026



 

 

Post a Comment

0Comments

Post a Comment (0)